There are a number of sites that have been created to help establish an online community for rock climbing enthusiasts. There are also several sites you can buy the gear you need to get started. I have yet to find one that combines both. That is one of my goals for this project is to create a place for beginners in rock climbing to learn more about the sport and to be able to learn from experienced climbers. I am also including an e-commerce side to the site that will allow users to purchase their gear directly instead of having to go to another site. Here are the sites I have found that directly relate to my final project topic: (Click on the screenshots to get to the sites or you can click the links provided below them.)

RockClimbing.com Screenshot
Rockclimbing.com is a very extensive site when it comes to obtaining information about the sport. The partners link was a bit confusing at first. I thought it had something to do with business partners, but instead it is a way to find a climbing partner. You have to sign-up to search the database but despite that I think it is a very useful feature. Since my site is going to be focused within the Dallas Fort-Worth area I’m mainly going to point users to clubs and organizations available in the area. They can find people to climb with that way. Personally I would be more comfortable finding a partner that way than trying to find an individual through a database of people.
When I first found this site I thought that I had found one that had successfully combined the e-commerce side with the community side. Sadly, it doesn’t have both. The gear link takes you to a page that lists different gear according to a category and provides reviews for each type. When I tried to purchase some of the gear it reroutes me to a different site.
The reviews are really helpful but there aren’t a whole lot of users posting reviews. The most I could find were 1 or 2 reviews and only on a few items. That isn’t the creators of the website fault but it would be nice to see more than a couple reviews on an item. Majority of the items didn’t even have reviews. I’m curious if the people that created the site have tried out any of the equipment. It would be nice to see some of their opinions on the gear.
They have a classified section feature on the site. I considered having that feature added to my project but decided against it. I want the site to be more of a learning opportunity for climbers and hopefully create a teacher/student relationship between beginners and advanced climbers. While also including the ability to purchase gear directly from the site. I don’t really want to add a classified section but would be happy to post specials and sales available on gear in the area. Overall the site is constructed well. I think if the main nav is taking up the full screen it would seem appropriate for the information to follow suit. Either have the navigation fit to the content or the content fit to the navigation don’t try to do both. That is one of the design decisions I don’t completely agree with.

Screenshot of the ABC of Rockclimbing site portal
The ABC of Rockclimbing is a nicely designed site. The pictures of people rockclimbing definitely helps it to stand out against the previous site above. People for the most part are visual creatures so I think it is really important to included pictures on the home page of your site. One thing that I noticed on the site is the Flash tutorial guide. It shows you how to tie climbing knots through flash based animations. I thought that was pretty cool and a feature I definitely want to include in my site. Since my site is mainly focused towards beginners the ability for them to see an animated demonstration on something they need to know would be very helpful.
They also are a good resource of information to learn more about rockclimbing, techniques, history of the sport, styles, etc. I also like the feature they have that allows you to compare prices across all manufactures for a specific type of gear you might need. The ABC of Rockclimbing is a sub-site of Maxlifestyle.net. They provide information on a number of different subjects besides rockclimbing. They have established a community through a forum (like rockclimbing.com) and allow users to share pictures. Still although they have price information on gear and discounts you can’t buy directly from the site. You have to purchase from one of the available retailers.
The community is forum based where as for my project I’m going to go more along the lines of blogging. I have nothing against forums it is just that the demographic I’m trying to reach for my site doesn’t necessrily use forums quite as much as other forms of online social media.
The site also includes a News section, which is another feature I will be adding to my project. I want to provide news on environmental, political and cultural issues that will or have effected the climbing community.

Screenshot of Rock climbing for life website
Rock Climbing for Life is a really informative site and like my project idea seems to be targeted towards beginners. Overall there are a number of navigational and poor design problems with this site. One problem can be seen easily from the screenshot of the home page. Half of the text is missing for what appears to be some type of offer. There are also some typos in the site. The illustration that is shown on all the pages is really nice and I’m curious of the person that created the site did it or not. If they did I fail to understand how come the rest of the site wasn’t designed with as much attention to detail as the illustration. The section on gear is very detailed and thorough it talks about the different types of gear required and what isn’t required. The writer tries to engage the audience with his descriptions which is always a nice quality to have in writing. Especially cause sometimes descriptions can come across as boring.
In regards to the site navigation it is pretty straight forward. Two of the links RCME and Free Course need some work. The RCME link takes you to what seems to be another home page design. The Home link doesn’t take you back to the original site you have to use the back button to get back to it. The Contact Us link takes you back to the familiar site navigation but it is the only one that does that. The Free Course link takes you to a page without any navigation on it and the only way to get back to the home page is with the back button. The typography hierarchy isn’t well thought out on those pages either with most of the text appearing to scream at the user. Also another thing I noticed about the FAQ link it keeps you on that different page but an additional link that wasn’t there before pops-up called Join Now. It leads you back to the original home page but it says there is no such url. Overall informative site but it needs work on both design and navigation.

Screenshot of YourClimbing.com site
YourClimbing.com is similar to the ABC of Rockclimbing.com but only because it is part of a group of sites. Enthusiast Group is incharge of the Your(InsertName).com sites. YourClimbing.com also provides links to YourRunning, YourCycling and YourMTB. They all seem to be based off the same template and aren’t designed very well with some of the pictures posted getting stretched and distorted. Also the typography hierarchy isn’t very well thought out and neither is the negative and postive spaces within the page design. One thing I found most annoying about the site is that it seems to really push users to sign-up for the newsletter. It shows up at the top of almost every page. Hopefully it goes away for users that have signed up but I don’t know for sure.
I do appreciate that a brief description about the site is provided on the main page. The concept for the logo is a good start but it could be executed better. For one the .com needs to be next to the word climbing not underneath it. Also the typeface choice for the word climbing doesn’t really work well with the typeface for YOUR and .COM. The main nav is a bit frustrating in that it combines pop-ups and drop down menus.
The content looks like it could be setup so much better without having so much empty space. The blog available on the site seems to have a thriving community of participants which is always crucial on any community based site. It seemd to be the only feature that was worth looking into. It didn’t have any information that I could find about the rockclimbing, introduction to gear or anything. There are photos and videos and some fictional stories but not really much information beyond that. There may be more available if you sign up but I don’t see the point in requiring someone to sign-up to get information. I plan on the majority of the site for my project to be open to the public with little to no sign-up areas.

Screenshot of Bouldering.com website
Bouldering.com didn’t really provide an about us section or any information about the company for that matter. It is obvious from first glance this is an e-commerce site for rock climbing, primarily bouldering which is a style of the sport. There isn’t any community section available on the site. I do like the clean design of the site. It does provide nice descriptions on each of its’ products as well as the option to add them to a wish list. The ability for users to add items to store for a later purchase is one I am seriously considering adding to the feature list of my project. It saves the user time from having to search for that specific item again when they are ready to come back and purchase it.
I like the large picture advertising the free shipping offer. The page layout of the site is executed well and makes it easy to navigate. It is very similar to the type of layout I have setup for the e-commerce side of my site design with some slight differences. One being I plan on having larger pictures of the products. For example when a user selects a specific product it is large enough for the user to see as much detail is possible. Also for the wearable items a size chart will be available with instructions to get the best fit.
Evaluating these sites have given me insight on what I can use to improve my project and what I need to avoid in order for it to be successful.